Why does a creek flood do damage out of proportion to its depth?
Because the damage is set by contact and absorption, not by depth. A few inches of creek water in a crawl space wets insulation, the underside of the subfloor and the sill plate, and those are structural or hard to reach. The shallow jobs are often the ones left untouched longest, which is what makes them expensive.
Absorbent material does not care how deep the water was. Fiberglass batt sitting in two inches of creek water wicks it upward and then holds it, insulated from the air that could dry it by its own position between joists. Wood takes water in through end grain at the joist ends and the sill, which is both the slowest place to dry and the worst place to leave wet.
Does development upstream make this worse?
Officials in Granville Township link more regular Raccoon Creek flooding to development and runoff, according to a local report. The mechanism is simple: roofs, drives and roads shed rain instead of absorbing it, so the same storm sends more water to the creek faster. A property's flood history is therefore not a fixed measure.
For a homeowner this changes what counts as evidence. If the last flood on your street was decades ago, that tells you less than it used to, because the ground above you may handle rain differently now than it did then. Looking at where water went in the most recent heavy rain is better information than looking at where it went in a historic event.
What moves the scope of a creek flood job up or down?
How long the water was in contact, how much absorbent material it touched, whether the wet zone is a crawl space or a finished room, the headroom and access the crew has, and how the building is constructed. Everything is measured on site, written up, explained and approved before the work starts.
Access dominates on this kind of job more than on any other. A crawl space with eighteen inches of headroom and one small hatch takes far longer to clear and dry than a basement a crew can carry equipment into standing upright. Distance from where a truck can park to where the water is matters for the same reason.
Construction type decides how much comes out. A sealed crawl space with a proper barrier and foam at the rim may need the barrier replaced and little else. A vented one with fiberglass batt stapled between the joists usually loses all of that insulation, because wet batt is not something worth drying in place.
Should the crawl space be left open to dry out by itself?
Usually not. Open vents exchange air with the outside, and after a spring rain in Ohio that outside air is often wetter than the air you are trying to dry. Drying works when the air around the wet material is held drier than the material, which takes a dehumidifier and a contained space.
This is the single most common thing we are asked to undo. A homeowner opens everything up and puts a box fan at the hatch, and three weeks later the joists read the same as they did on day one. The fan moved air, but the air it moved was already near saturation, so there was nowhere for the moisture in the wood to go.
Standing water also has to be out before any of it means anything. A crawl space with water on the ground is a humidifier running continuously under your floor. Removal, then cleaning, then a contained drying setup with readings, in that order, is what actually gets wood back to a safe moisture content. See how long structural drying takes for what a realistic timeline looks like.