Does a damp crawl space matter if the house above seems fine?
Yes, because the structure above is what the moisture reaches. Joists, subfloor and sill held at a high moisture content for long periods can decay, growth establishes on the underside of the floor, and damp air carries both the humidity and the smell up into the living space through the floor.
Buildings move air upward. Warm air in the house rises and leaves at the top, which draws replacement air in lower down, and in a house over a crawl space a good share of that replacement air comes up through the floor. Whatever the crawl space smells like is therefore what part of the house is breathing.
The structural side is slower and more expensive. A joist end or a sill plate held damp for years does not announce itself until a floor feels soft, and by then the repair is carpentry rather than drying. Checking the space after any wet spell, and dealing with moisture while it is just moisture, is what avoids that.
Should a crawl space be vented or sealed?
The current direction of practice is to control ground moisture with a good barrier and manage the air inside the space, rather than to vent it to the weather. Open vents in a humid Ohio summer bring in air that is wetter than the air inside, which is the opposite of drying. The permanent design is a builder's decision.
What a restoration crew contributes is the evidence: what the space reads, where the moisture is coming from, what the framing is holding, and how the space responds to controlled drying. Those readings are what a sensible permanent solution should be designed around.
What we can say plainly is which approaches do not work. A box fan at a hatch, vents propped open in July, and a dehumidifier running in a space with standing water on the ground all fail for the same reason: they add air movement without changing the water supply. Deal with the ground and the inflow, and then the air.
What determines the scope of this work?
Headroom and access first, then the area, how much absorbent material is involved, how long the dampness has been present, whether there is growth, and whether masonry is holding water. The scope is measured at the property, written out, explained to you and approved before work begins.
Access is the dominant factor in a crawl space. Low clearance and a single small hatch mean everything, equipment, insulation, debris and bags, moves in and out through that opening by hand. The same work in a basement a crew can walk into is markedly quicker.
Duration decides whether this is a drying job or a cleaning job as well. Moisture found after one wet season is usually clearing, removal and drying. A space that has been damp for a decade normally has growth on the subfloor and framing, which brings containment, controlled removal and cleaning into the work before any drying starts.
How does this relate to flooding in the valley?
Directly. Newark sits where the North Fork, South Fork and main Licking River meet, and the USGS reports most flood damage in Licking County along those streams and Raccoon Creek. Where a basement or crawl space has held water, the drying afterwards is this work, and so is the monitoring until the ground around the building gives up its own moisture.
A property near one of those streams also experiences a rising water table every time the stream is high, whether or not water comes into the building. That is enough to keep a crawl space damp for weeks and to keep a block wall loaded with moisture, which is why readings in masonry matter so much here.
For a property with repeat exposure, the sensible long-term response is to keep absorbent material out of the lowest part of the structure and to get surface and roof water away from the building. Newark promotes disconnecting downspouts, and getting that discharge out onto the surface and well away from the wall is one of the cheapest improvements available.