The Buckeye Lake dam was rebuilt after a 2015 Army Corps review found the old structure at risk of failure, and the new 4.1-mile dam opened in November 2018. A sound dam addresses dam failure. It does not stop runoff, high lake levels or spring water on low ground, which is what most lake edge water losses are.
Key takeaways
- A 2015 Army Corps of Engineers review found the old Buckeye Lake dam at risk of failure.
- The replacement is 4.1 miles long and opened in November 2018 at roughly $107 million, though published figures vary.
- Several hundred homes, docks and other structures had been built into the old dam, which is why the project was so complicated.
- A rebuilt dam answers the question of catastrophic failure, not the question of runoff onto low ground.
- On the Fairfield County side, residents at Millersport describe spring flooding as routine, and the county installed storm drain lines and pumps along the west bank in 2020.
- Lake water, runoff and drain water are handled as contaminated, so soaked porous material is removed rather than dried.
What was actually wrong with the old dam?
A review by the Army Corps of Engineers in 2015 found the old structure at risk of failure. The replacement that followed runs 4.1 miles and opened in November 2018, with published costs around $107 million against roughly $150 million approved, and reports differ.
The complication was not only engineering. Several hundred homes, docks and other structures had been built into the old dam over the years, which meant the project had to be delivered through a developed lakeshore rather than across open ground. That is an unusual constraint for a flood-control structure and it shaped the schedule and the price.
Figures for the finished project vary between published accounts, with some putting it nearer $100 million and some nearer $110 million, so the honest summary is roughly $107 million. The useful point for a homeowner is not the total but the reason the work was done: a structure in that condition holding a lake above occupied ground.
What does a sound dam change for a lake edge house?
It changes the worst case. A dam at risk of failure is a different category of threat from a wet spring, and that threat has been addressed. What it does not touch is water arriving from rainfall, runoff and lake level on low-lying ground.
These two things get conflated constantly in conversation around the lake, and it is worth keeping them apart. The dam governs whether the lake stays where it is supposed to be. Drainage governs whether rain that falls on your street finds somewhere to go. A rebuilt dam leaves the second question exactly where it was.
So the practical risk for most lake edge properties did not change in November 2018. Low ground is still low ground, a yard that drains toward the house still drains toward the house, and a cellar below the water table is still below it. Those are the conditions that produce the ordinary water loss here.
What does the flooding around the lake actually look like?
Shallow water on low streets and yards after heavy or sustained rain, water finding its way into cellars and crawl spaces, and the same addresses affected repeatedly. Residents on the west bank describe it as a spring event rather than a rare one.
At Millersport, on the Fairfield County side, Sellers Drive was covered in water in July 2025 after overnight rain, and residents said spring flooding happens every year, with one describing the area as a retention pond for the surrounding runoff. In 2020 Fairfield County installed storm drain lines and pumps along the west bank to protect homes there.
That pattern is what a crew expects to be called to around the lake: not a wall of water, but repeated shallow intrusion into the lowest part of a building. It is less dramatic than a river flood and it does the same thing to carpet, pad, insulation and the base of a wall.
Which communities sit on the lake, and how do they differ?
The village of Buckeye Lake, with a population of about 3,200, is on the north side in Union Township. Millersport sits on the west bank in Fairfield County. Thornville is in Perry County to the east, and Hebron lies a couple of miles from the dam.
The county lines matter more than the distances, because drainage work, storm infrastructure and the authorities to approach are all organized by jurisdiction. The west bank improvements were a Fairfield County undertaking. A property on the north side is in Licking County and a property to the east may be in Perry County, with different offices to ask.
Housing differs too. Buckeye Lake grew up around the water with a long history of seasonal and converted cottages, while properties marketed as lake-edge homes appear in listings around Thornville as well. A converted cottage with a shallow crawl space has nothing in common with a modern house on a full foundation when water arrives.
Why is lake and runoff water not treated as clean?
Because it has crossed open ground, roads, yards and often a drainage system before it reaches a building. Water that arrives over the ground is handled as grossly contaminated, so porous materials it soaked are removed rather than dried in place.
That is the single biggest difference between this kind of loss and a burst pipe. A supply line failure can sometimes be dried where it lies, with a low cut at the base of the drywall. Water that came off the street takes carpet, pad, wall insulation and the lower band of board with it, whatever the depth looked like.
The sequence is also different: remove what cannot be saved, clean and disinfect what stays, and only then dry to measured readings. Drying a contaminated space before it is cleaned simply dries the contamination into the structure. Ask any crew to state the water category it has assigned and what follows from it.
What about crawl spaces and seasonal buildings?
They are the hardest part of lake-edge work. A crawl space holds water out of sight, dries badly because air does not move through it, and sits directly under the floor you walk on. A building that is closed for part of the year hides a loss for months.
Water under a floor wets the subfloor from below, which is the direction nobody checks. A technician reads the underside, the joists and the band at the perimeter, and insulation in a wet crawl space normally comes out because it holds water and gives it back very slowly. Ground cover and ventilation details are part of the conversation afterward.
If a property is empty for stretches, the single most useful thing is someone looking at it after heavy rain and after a hard freeze. A loss found in week one is a drying job; the same loss found in month three is usually a removal job. That difference is larger than anything a crew can do once it arrives.
What can an owner do before the next wet spring?
Get water away from the building, keep the lowest floor clear of anything absorbent, make sure any pump works and has a plan for a power cut, and know where the shutoffs are. Then ask the right office about drainage on your street.
Downspouts discharging at the wall, grading that falls back toward the house and a window well with nowhere to drain are the three cheap fixes, and they matter more on flat lake-edge ground than almost anywhere else. Raising stored belongings off the floor costs nothing and saves the things people are most upset to lose.
On drainage, approach the authority for your side of the lake, since the west bank work was a county project and the lake touches more than one county. Licking County also maintains countywide hazard mitigation planning in which Newark participates, and the USGS publishes flood-inundation mapping for the main streams in the county.
Does the dam have anything to do with Newark's river flooding?
No. They are separate systems with separate histories. Newark's flooding comes from the Licking River and its forks, and the Buckeye Lake dam holds a lake southwest of the city. Dillon Dam, a federal flood-control project, sits downstream in Muskingum County.
Dillon Dam and Lake were built by the Army Corps of Engineers primarily for flood control, authorized by the Flood Control Act of 1938 and completed in 1960 or 1961 depending on the source, as part of the Ohio River Basin program supplementing the Muskingum reservoirs. It lies downstream of Newark rather than above it.
Keeping those structures straight matters when you are reading about a wet season. A lake level story, a dam story and a river crest story are three different things with three different implications for your house. Our first 48 hours guide deals with the river side, and this page with the lake.
Frequently asked questions
Is the lake safe now that the dam has been rebuilt?
The risk the 2015 review identified was the condition of the old structure, and that structure has been replaced by a 4.1-mile dam that opened in November 2018. What has not changed is ordinary drainage: rain still falls on low ground and still finds the lowest opening in a building. Treat those as two separate questions about your property.
My cellar takes water every spring. Is that a dam issue?
Almost certainly not. Repeated seasonal water is a drainage and groundwater pattern, and residents on the west bank describe exactly that, which is why Fairfield County installed storm drain lines and pumps there in 2020. Start with where water arrives at your own building, then take the street-level pattern to the authority for your side of the lake.
Can lake water be dried out of a carpet?
Not reliably, and that is not how it is handled. Water that has crossed open ground is treated as grossly contaminated, so carpet, pad and wall insulation it soaked are taken out, the space is cleaned, and drying follows afterward. Hard, non-porous surfaces are cleaned and kept. Expect a written removal list with photographs before anything leaves.
Does it matter which county my property is in?
For the cleanup, no. For drainage, permits and who to ask about street-level flooding, yes. The lake touches more than one county: Millersport is in Fairfield County, the village of Buckeye Lake is in Licking County, and Thornville is in Perry County. Ask the local building department about anything structural you plan to change.
The building is only used in summer. What should I check?
Have someone look at it after heavy rain and after a hard freeze, and open it up before the season rather than on the first warm weekend. Water found early is a drying job; water found months later usually means removal. Check the crawl space from below if you can get to it, since that is where a loss hides longest.
Who do I call when water is already inside?
Call the cleanup line first for the water itself, whatever the hour: phones are answered 24/7 and a crew is sent as soon as one is free, with no arrival time promised. Call (833) 490-5225 and say whether the water came from outside, from a drain or from a pipe, because that decides what the first visit can do.
Sources
This guide is general information for Licking County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.